FOIA Crash Course
The FOIA series
- FOIA Crash Course — the overview (you are here)
- Part 1: How to Write a Request
- Part 2: Tracking Requests and Working with Records Officers
- Part 3: When It Gets Difficult
- Part 4: Filing a Federal FOIA Request
- Examples: Weak, Better, and Why
In Michigan? Our Michigan guides cover the state’s law in detail: How to Write a Request and When It Gets Difficult.
The short version
The Freedom of Information Act — FOIA, usually said “FOY-uh” — and the state laws modeled on it let you get copies of government records. Emails, contracts, letters, reports, maps, meeting materials: if a public body made it or keeps it, you can probably ask for it.
It’s the single most powerful tool an ordinary person has for finding out what’s really happening with a project. Almost everything I’ve learned that officials didn’t volunteer, I learned through records requests. You don’t need a lawyer, a press pass or any special standing. You need to know which law to use, how to ask clearly, and how to keep at it.
This page is the overview. Each step of the process has its own detailed guide, linked below, and each Great Lakes state has its own resource page with its official guides.
I’m not a lawyer, and this isn’t legal advice. Deadlines and rules are cited to their sources so you can check them, and laws do change.
Why we use it
- To find out what’s actually been decided. Public presentations show the finished picture. The records show how it got there — who talked to whom, what was promised, and when.
- To check what you’ve been told. When an official says something at a meeting, the records will either back it up or they won’t.
- To turn suspicions into facts. A rumor gets dismissed. A document gets answered. See “Someone Told Me” vs. “I Have a Document That Says”.
- To level the playing field. Developers and agencies have staff, lawyers and consultants. Records laws give residents access to the same underlying information.
- To create a public record. Once a document is released, anyone can read it, cite it and build on it.
Two kinds of law: your state’s and the federal government’s
This is the first thing that trips people up. There isn’t one FOIA. There’s a federal Freedom of Information Act for federal agencies, and every state has its own law for state and local government — under names like Freedom of Information Act, Right-to-Know Law or Public Records Act. They work similarly, but deadlines, fees and appeal rules differ, so it matters which one you’re using.
Which law applies?
It depends on who holds the records, not on what the project is about.
| If the records are held by… | Use… |
|---|---|
| Your township, city, village, county, school district or local authority | Your state’s records law |
| A state agency — the environmental agency, the economic development agency, the utility commission | Your state’s records law |
| A public university | Your state’s records law |
| A federal agency — the EPA, Department of Energy, Army Corps of Engineers, FAA, FEMA | Federal FOIA |
| A national laboratory run by a contractor for the federal government | Generally, federal FOIA to the agency that oversees it |
| A private company | Neither directly — but its letters, applications and reports are reachable through whichever public body received them |
| A governor’s office, legislature or court | Often limited or exempt, depending on the state — request the records from the agency on the other end of the correspondence |
| Congress or the federal courts | Not covered by federal FOIA |
Many projects involve both. A single project can leave records with a township, a state agency, a university and a federal agency at the same time — and each copy of the same letter can be requested separately.
The Great Lakes states at a glance
The biggest practical difference between states is what happens after a denial: whether there’s a free state office to help, or whether you have to go to court. Part 1 compares response deadlines, and Part 3 compares appeals in detail.
| State | Law | Free help after a denial |
|---|---|---|
| Illinois | Freedom of Information Act | Public Access Counselor — can issue binding opinions |
| Indiana | Access to Public Records Act | Public Access Counselor — advisory opinions |
| Michigan | Freedom of Information Act | Appeal to the public body’s head; otherwise court (with attorney fees if you win) |
| Minnesota | Government Data Practices Act | Data Practices Office and Commissioner advisory opinions |
| New York | Freedom of Information Law | Agency appeal; Committee on Open Government advisory opinions |
| Ohio | Public Records Act | Low-cost Court of Claims complaint, starting with mediation |
| Pennsylvania | Right-to-Know Law | Office of Open Records — binding decisions |
| Wisconsin | Public Records Law | Ask the district attorney or Attorney General; otherwise court |
The federal FOIA in brief
- The law: 5 U.S.C. § 552. Anyone can file, through the agency’s FOIA office or the national portal, FOIA.gov.
- Deadline: 20 working days, with up to 10 more in “unusual circumstances.” In practice, many agencies have long backlogs.
- Fees: depend on who you are; ordinary requesters get the first 2 hours of search and 100 pages free, and fee waivers are available for requests in the public interest.
- Appeals: to the agency within 90 days; free mediation through the Office of Government Information Services; then federal court.
Sources: the U.S. Department of Justice’s Office of Information Policy and agency FOIA guidance, such as the Office of Personnel Management’s. Details are in Part 4.
The process, start to finish
- Check what’s already public. Meeting packets, permits and many reports are online. Requesting something that’s already posted wastes weeks. → Doing Your Own Research
- Figure out who holds the records and which law applies — using the table above. Parts 1–3 cover state records laws; for federal agencies, see → Part 4: Filing a Federal FOIA Request
- Write a specific request. The type of record, the people involved, the date range and keywords. A vague request gets a big bill; a specific one gets records. → Part 1: How to Write a Request and Examples: Weak, Better, and Why
- Track it. Log the date, the reference number and every deadline, and follow up in writing when one passes. → Part 2: Tracking Requests and Working with Records Officers
- Work with the records officer. Be courteous, put phone calls in writing, and narrow in good faith if a request is broader than you meant. → Part 2
- Review what comes back. Check fee estimates, redactions and the exemptions cited. Huge estimates, “no records found” and heavy redactions all have answers. → Part 3: When It Gets Difficult
- Appeal if you need to — on time. Denials and excessive fees can both be challenged, but some states’ deadlines are short. → Part 3
- Organize and share. Keep originals untouched, index what you received, and protect private citizens’ personal information before posting anything. → Part 2
What to expect
- It takes time. State and local requests can take weeks; federal ones can take months. Start early and file in parallel.
- Not every request succeeds. Some records are legitimately exempt, and some don’t exist. That’s normal, and a “no records” answer can itself be useful information.
- Persistence pays. The best documents often come from a second or third request, written with what you learned from the first.
- You’re not alone. Other residents, local reporters and open-government groups have done this before and are often glad to help.
Related tools
- Open meetings laws require public bodies to make decisions in meetings open to the public. Records laws get you documents; open meetings laws govern how decisions are made.
- The federal Privacy Act lets you request records a federal agency keeps about you.
- Public notices from your state environmental agency tell you when you can comment on a permit before a decision is made. Each state resource page links to them.
Example: one project, many record-keepers
The Textile Road project in Ypsilanti Township left records with the University of Michigan, the Michigan Economic Development Corporation, the state environmental agency and the township — all reachable under Michigan’s FOIA — and with the federal agencies that oversee Los Alamos National Laboratory, reachable under the federal law. See some of what turned up: the seven confidentiality agreements, the University’s agreement with Los Alamos, and the MEDC’s $400 million letter.
Resources
State records laws
- State resource pages — official guides and open-government offices for each Great Lakes state.
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press — Open Government Guide — detailed guides to every state’s records and meetings laws.
Federal
- FOIA.gov — the national portal for filing with federal agencies
- U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Information Policy — the federal government’s FOIA guidance
- Office of Government Information Services (OGIS) — free mediation for federal FOIA disputes
Both
- MuckRock — files and tracks state and federal requests and publishes the results