Truth, Rumor, and Fact
The short version
In any fight over a big project, information moves fast — through Facebook groups, group texts, meetings and conversations at the grocery store. Some of it is solid. Some of it is half-right. Some of it is simply wrong. And once a wrong claim gets repeated enough, it starts to feel true to everyone.
Sorting what you know from what you’ve heard isn’t about being cautious for its own sake. It’s what keeps a community credible. Officials, reporters and judges will listen to people who are careful with facts, and they’ll stop listening to people who aren’t.
Four kinds of information
It helps to put everything you hear into one of four buckets:
| Kind | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Documented fact | A primary source says it, and you’ve read it yourself | “The approved minutes of the October 14 meeting record a 5–2 vote.” |
| Reported claim | A news story, official or other credible person says it, but you haven’t seen the underlying record | “The newspaper reported the company expects 50 jobs.” |
| Inference | A reasonable conclusion you’ve drawn from facts — but not something any document actually says | “Since the land was bought before the public meeting, the decision was likely made earlier.” |
| Rumor | Something heard secondhand, with no source you can point to | “Someone at the gas station said they’ll start building in March.” |
All four have their place. Rumors can be useful leads, and inferences are how you figure out what to look for next. The trouble starts when one kind gets passed along as another — when an inference gets repeated as a fact, or a rumor gets repeated until it sounds documented.
How to check something
- Find the original source. Not the post about the article about the document — the document itself.
- Read the whole thing. A sentence can mean something quite different in context. Check what comes right before and after a quote.
- Check the date. Plans change. A 2024 estimate may have been replaced by a 2026 one.
- Check who’s saying it, and how they’d know. A utility engineer describing their own system is different from a commenter guessing about it.
- Look for a second, independent source. Two people repeating the same post don’t count as two sources.
- Be suspicious of what you want to believe. The claims most likely to slip past us are the ones that confirm what we already think.
Be especially careful about people
Claims about what an organization did can usually be checked against records. Claims about a person’s motives, honesty or secret dealings are different. They’re harder to prove, they can hurt someone who doesn’t deserve it, and stating them as fact can expose you to a defamation claim. Stick to what someone said and did on the record, and let readers draw their own conclusions.
Correct yourself, out loud
Everyone gets something wrong eventually. When you do, fix it plainly and say that you did. It feels uncomfortable, but it’s one of the most trust-building things a community group can do. It shows you care more about getting it right than about winning a point — and it makes everything else you say more believable.
Questions to ask before you share
- Have I seen the original source myself?
- Is this a fact, a reported claim, my own inference, or a rumor — and does the way I’m sharing it make that clear?
- Is it current?
- Would I be comfortable if the person or organization involved read exactly what I wrote?
- If it turned out to be wrong, what damage would it do — to someone else, or to our credibility?
Example: a correction from my own research
While researching the history of the University of Michigan’s former classified research lab, I wrote in my notes that in 1974 the lab’s successor tried to buy a building once owned by a defense contractor called Conductron. It fit neatly with other records I’d found, so I didn’t question it. Then a 1974 newspaper article turned up showing the building actually belonged to Bendix. I’d connected two things that seemed to go together without checking. It was a small thing, but it’s a good reminder: the moment a detail fits a little too neatly, that’s the moment to go check it.