FOIA, Part 3: When It Gets Difficult
The FOIA series
- FOIA Crash Course — the overview
- Part 1: How to Write a Request
- Part 2: Tracking Requests and Working with Records Officers
- Part 3: When It Gets Difficult (you are here)
- Part 4: Filing a Federal FOIA Request
- Examples: Weak, Better, and Why
In Michigan? Our Michigan guides cover the state’s law in detail: How to Write a Request and When It Gets Difficult.
The short version
Most records officers are doing a hard job honestly, and courtesy gets you a long way. But when a public body doesn’t want something released, there are a handful of tactics you’ll run into again and again: a fee estimate big enough to make you quit, a missed deadline, “no records found,” or pages of black boxes. Each one has an answer.
The first rule: keep everything in writing. If it isn’t in writing, it didn’t happen.
I’m not a lawyer, and this isn’t legal advice. Appeal routes and deadlines differ by state — some are short and strict — so check your state’s official guide, linked from its state resource page.
“That will cost $2,000”
A huge estimate is the most common way a request dies, because most people simply give up. Here’s how to respond:
- Check the itemization. Are the hourly rates and hours plausible? Are they charging for paper when you asked for electronic copies? Does the fee match what your state’s law allows?
- Send a narrowing letter. Ask what’s driving the cost — usually a broad keyword search or a long date range — and narrow to specific people, a tighter window, or named documents.
- Ask for rolling production. Pay for the first batch and decide whether to continue once you see what’s in it.
- Challenge the fee if it exceeds what the law allows. Some states have a separate process for fee disputes.
They’re late
Send a polite, dated follow-up that cites the deadline in your state’s law and asks when you can expect the records. In many states, a missed deadline counts as a denial — sometimes called a “deemed denial” or “constructive denial” — which you can appeal. Be careful: in some states, the appeal clock starts when the deadline passes, even if you’re still waiting politely. Pennsylvania’s Office of Open Records, for example, regularly dismisses appeals filed after its 15-business-day window.
“No responsive records exist”
Sometimes that’s true. When it isn’t, it’s usually because the search was too narrow. Then:
- ask what was searched — which accounts, which offices, which terms;
- refile with different terms, the names of specific people, or a known date;
- if you have evidence the record exists — someone referred to it in a meeting, or another agency produced its copy — say so in an appeal.
Records held by one public body are often held by another. When one door closes, try the other party to the correspondence: the agency that received the letter, the township that attended the meeting, the state office that processed the grant.
Pages of black boxes
Exemptions are allowed, but most states’ laws limit how they’re used:
- Separate, don’t withhold whole. If a record has exempt and nonexempt parts, the nonexempt parts generally must be released.
- Explain every denial. A denial should cite the specific exemption it relies on.
- The burden is usually theirs. In most states, the public body has to justify an exemption, not the requester.
The exemptions you’re most likely to see go by different names in different states, but they look much the same:
| Exemption | What it covers | Where it’s often stretched |
|---|---|---|
| Personal privacy | Personal information whose release would be an unwarranted invasion of privacy | Used to black out names of officials or business contacts acting in an official capacity. Their official actions generally aren’t private. |
| Internal deliberations | Drafts, opinions and recommendations made before a decision — often called “deliberative” or “predecisional” material | Usually covers opinions, not facts. Factual material inside a draft is often still public. |
| Trade secrets and confidential business information | Commercial or financial information a company provided in confidence | Many states limit it to information that’s genuinely confidential and properly designated — not everything a company labels “confidential.” |
| Security | Security plans and critical-infrastructure details | Applies to genuine security measures, not ordinary planning documents, budgets or utility demand figures. |
| Attorney-client privilege | Legal advice from an attorney | Doesn’t cover business discussions just because a lawyer was copied. |
Appeals in the Great Lakes states
This is where states differ most. Some have a free state office that can review your denial; others send you to the agency’s head or to court. Find out your deadline right away — it can be as short as 15 business days.
| State | How to challenge a denial |
|---|---|
| Illinois | File a request for review with the Attorney General’s Public Access Counselor within 60 days; it can resolve the dispute or issue a binding opinion. You can also go to court. |
| Indiana | File a free formal complaint with the Public Access Counselor, who issues an advisory opinion; you can also go to court. |
| Michigan | Appeal to the head of the public body, or go straight to court, within 180 days (45 days for fee disputes). Winning in court can mean attorney fees and penalties. See our Michigan guide. |
| Minnesota | Ask the Commissioner of Administration for an advisory opinion, which courts must give deference; you can also go to court. |
| New York | File a written appeal with the agency within 30 days; it has 10 business days to decide. Then go to court under Article 78. The Committee on Open Government can also issue an advisory opinion. |
| Ohio | File a low-cost complaint with the Court of Claims, which starts with mediation, or go to court. |
| Pennsylvania | Appeal to the Office of Open Records within 15 business days; it issues a binding decision, usually within 30 days, which can be appealed to court. |
| Wisconsin | Go to court, or ask the local district attorney or the Attorney General to act. |
A sample appeal
Whatever the route, a good appeal uses the word “appeal,” includes copies of your request and the response, and explains specifically why the denial was wrong.
Subject: APPEAL — Public records request dated [date], [reference number] To [the official or office that hears appeals]: Under [your state's public records law and appeal provision], I appeal the [denial / partial denial] of my request dated [date], which I received on [date]. Copies of the request and the response are attached. The denial was improper because: 1. [e.g., The response withheld entire documents rather than releasing their nonexempt portions.] 2. [e.g., The response did not identify the specific exemption relied on for each withholding.] 3. [e.g., The response stated that no records exist, but the [date] meeting minutes refer to the [document].] I ask that you reverse the denial and release the records. Sincerely, [Name, address, email, phone]
Example: a $2,000 estimate in Ypsilanti Township
Two of our requests to the Michigan Economic Development Corporation each came back estimated at roughly 4,000 pages and about $2,000. The answer wasn’t to pay or quit; it was to narrow — to specific people, a shorter date range and named documents. A request for one specific letter between two officials is cheap; “all records about the project” is not.
Resources
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press — Open Government Guide — every state’s exemptions and appeal process, with case law.
- MuckRock — files and tracks requests and publishes the results.
- State resource pages — each Great Lakes state’s official records guide and open-government office.
Previous: FOIA, Part 2: Tracking Requests and Working with Records Officers
Next: FOIA, Part 4: Filing a Federal FOIA Request