The University Told the State This Land Is Contaminated
The University has filed Baseline Environmental Assessments with the State for all three Textile Road parcels, recording each as a “facility” under Part 201 — contamination above generic residential cleanup criteria.
I wrote about those filings when I first obtained them. A later records request produced something better: EGLE’s own internal Master Data Forms, dated October 1, 2026, which contain the State’s assessment rather than the University’s consultant’s.
They change the picture in both directions, and I’ve rewritten this page around them. One thing I got wrong is corrected at the bottom.
The State rates the two sites very differently
This is the finding that matters most, and it isn’t in the assessments themselves. It’s EGLE’s classification.
| 10455 & 10635 Textile (118 acres) | 10221 Textile (20 acres) | |
|---|---|---|
| EGLE risk condition | Risks Controlled-Interim | Risks Present and Require Action in Long-term |
| Contaminants of concern | Elements / Metals / Other Inorganics | Elements / Metals / Other Inorganics, Lead, Mercury, Petroleum Volatile and Semi Volatile Organic Compounds |
| Groundwater | No exceedances | Lead above criteria |
| Soil gas | No exceedances | tert-Butylbenzene above criteria |
| Business type on record | Agriculture | Agriculture, Vacant |
Source: EGLE Master Data Forms, October 1, 2026 — 10221 Textile and 10455/10635 Textile.3 Both are four pages; the risk condition is on page one of each.
“Risks Present and Require Action in Long-term” is the State’s own words about the 20-acre parcel — the first piece of land the University bought here.
Where the contamination comes from
Here is the part I had wrong in my head, and it’s more serious than what I’d assumed.
The 20-acre parcel’s own history is unremarkable. Per EGLE: residential and agricultural use from at least 1902 through 1937, a baseball field on the southeastern portion by 1983, out of use and reverted to vacant land by 2005. No structures on it today.3
The problem is next door. EGLE records two Recognized Environmental Conditions:
- The southern adjacent property, used for industrial purposes since at least 1956, with five confirmed leaking underground storage tank releases.
- The western adjacent property, with contamination exceeding residential and/or nonresidential Volatilization to Indoor Air Pathway screening levels.
That explains the petroleum compounds in the contaminant list, and it explains why soil gas was tested here and not treated as an afterthought.
And the water is close
From EGLE’s own record of the 20-acre parcel:3
- Ford Lake: approximately 110 feet to the northwest.
- The Huron River: approximately 375 feet to the north.
- Presumed groundwater flow direction: to the north.
Groundwater at this parcel was found at 8 to 12 feet below the surface, and it flows toward the river.
What exceeded, exactly
These are EGLE’s figures, from its October 2024 sampling summary for the 20-acre parcel:3
Soil. Arsenic at 6,400 µg/kg, above residential Drinking Water Protection and Groundwater Surface Water Interface Protection criteria. Mercury at 91 µg/kg, above Groundwater Surface Water Interface Protection and residential Volatilization to Indoor Air screening levels. Silver at 410 µg/kg, above Groundwater Surface Water Interface Protection.
Groundwater. Lead at 16 µg/L, above residential Drinking Water criteria and Groundwater Surface Water Interface criteria.
Soil gas. tert-Butylbenzene at 19 µg/m³, above residential Volatilization to Indoor Air screening levels.
Note what most of those criteria have in common. Drinking Water Protection. Groundwater Surface Water Interface. Those are the standards that exist to protect water bodies — and the nearest one is 110 feet away.
The 118 acres are a different story
And I want to be as clear about this as about the rest, because it cuts the other way.
EGLE’s record for the larger parcels describes a farmstead and agricultural land from at least 1902 to the 1950s, with a rail spur along the southeastern boundary by 1973 and heavy woods since. The August 2025 investigation found three contaminants above criteria — arsenic at 7,100 µg/kg, chromium at 10,000, silver at 160 — all in soil.3
EGLE states plainly: The groundwater and soil gas analytical results revealed no concentrations of contaminants above criteria.
Arsenic and metals on former Michigan farmland are common, and frequently trace to decades of pesticide use — lead arsenate was standard for a very long time. The State’s classification of Risks Controlled-Interim
reflects that.
If the argument were only about the 118 acres, I’d say the environmental case is thin. It isn’t only about the 118 acres.
The timeline still matters
- September 30, 2024 — Phase I completed for the 20-acre parcel
- October 2024 — subsurface investigation: 5 borings to 15 feet, soil gas implants in 3 of them
- November 5, 2024 — the University takes ownership
- January 13, 2025 — first BEA filed with EGLE
- August 2025 — subsurface investigation on the Norfolk parcels
- March 18, 2026 — purchase closes
- March 26, 2026 — second BEA filed
Assessment before purchase, filing within the statutory window, both times. That is how the process is meant to work and I’ll say so plainly.
Which makes the silence harder to explain, not easier. None of this — not the risk classification, not the five releases next door, not the lead in groundwater 375 feet from the Huron — has ever been mentioned to this community by the University. The October 2026 postcard describes the project as safe and environmentally conscious
.4
At the October 1 town hall a panelist did say an initial baseline environmental assessment exists and is publicly available.5 That is accurate. It is available by asking the State, which is how I got it.
Update: I asked EGLE about due care, and they answered
I had assumed the due care documentation under Section 20107a was overdue. I asked EGLE directly. It isn’t, and their answer goes above mine.
Given that the property is currently vacant, and the current lack of potential ways to come into contact with or be exposed to the contaminants noted in the BEA, it does not appear that EGLE needs documentation of due care from the University of Michigan at this time.
EGLE, Remediation and Redevelopment Division6
They gave three reasons: there are no potable wells or other means to ingest or come into contact with the groundwater at the property; soil contaminants are two feet or more below ground surface, so people would not come into direct contact with them; and there are no buildings on site, so there are no current concerns for indoor air inhalation.
That is a clear answer and I accept it. Nobody is being exposed to anything today, and the University is not out of compliance with anything. If an earlier version of this page suggested otherwise, that was my error.
But read the three reasons again. Every one is a statement about an empty field.
No wells, because nobody draws water there. No direct contact with soil, because the contaminants sit two feet down and nothing is digging. No indoor air concern, because there are no buildings.
The plan is to excavate the site and put buildings on it.
Construction removes the first protection — excavation is precisely how soil two feet down reaches the surface, the air and the stormwater. Occupied buildings remove the third, which is why the soil gas result and the vapor intrusion exceedances on the adjacent property matter at all.
EGLE’s phrasing is careful and worth noticing: at this time. Their answer describes the site as it stands, not as it is proposed to be.
So the question isn’t whether the University has failed to file something. It hasn’t. The question is what happens the moment the ground is opened — and that is a document which does not exist yet, for a site the State classifies as having risks present and requiring action in the long term.
Worth asking now, while there is still time to plan for it.
The obligation itself
Owning a Part 201 facility carries obligations. Under Section 20107a, an owner must exercise due care — preventing exposure, stopping contamination from spreading, and not making it worse. Documentation has to be available to EGLE within eight months of taking ownership.
EGLE’s position is that this documentation isn’t required while the site sits empty. That obligation becomes live when the conditions change.
Which is the useful thing to ask the University for: not a document EGLE doesn’t currently require, but the plan for managing known contamination on land it intends to excavate, next to a property with five confirmed fuel releases, 375 feet from the Huron River.
What still needs answering
- Why has this community never been told that the State classifies the 20-acre parcel as having risks present and requiring long-term action?
- Will the University publish the due care documentation filed under Section 20107a?
- What vapor intrusion mitigation is designed into the buildings, given the soil gas result and the VIAP exceedances on the adjacent property?
- How will excavation avoid mobilizing contamination toward groundwater that flows north to the Huron River, 375 feet away?
- What stormwater controls apply during two to three years of construction, 110 feet from Ford Lake?
Correction
An earlier version of this page reported lead at 24,000 µg/kg in soil as one of the exceedances on the 20-acre parcel. That figure appears in the assessment’s sample tables, but EGLE’s own summary does not list soil lead among the contaminants exceeding criteria there. Michigan’s direct-contact criterion for lead in soil is far higher than that concentration.
The lead exceedance is in groundwater, at 16 µg/L, above both drinking water and groundwater-surface water interface criteria. That is a more specific finding and, given the direction of groundwater flow, arguably a more serious one — but I had the medium wrong and I’ve fixed it.
Sources
- Baseline Environmental Assessment 81000971-BEA-1, 10221 Textile Road, filed January 13, 2025 (PDF)
- Baseline Environmental Assessment 81000985-BEA-1, 10455 and 10635 Textile Road, filed March 26, 2026 (PDF)
- EGLE Remediation and Redevelopment Division, Master Data Forms dated October 1, 2026, obtained under the Freedom of Information Act — Location ID 81000971, 10221 Textile Road (PDF) · Location ID 81000985, 10455 and 10635 Textile Road (PDF). These are EGLE’s internal records, containing the State’s own risk classifications and narrative summaries.
- Postcard mailed to Ypsilanti Township households, October 2026 (PDF) · my analysis
- Correspondence from EGLE, Remediation and Redevelopment Division, in response to my inquiry about due care documentation under Section 20107a, October 2026.
- Public recording of the October 1, 2026 town hall. youtube.com · my account
I’m not an environmental professional. Everything above is quoted or calculated from documents linked here, including EGLE’s own internal records. If you work in this field and I’ve misread something, tell me and I’ll fix it and say that I did — as I have above.
Has this been shared with our Township Supervisor so comparative tests can be performed debunking UM’s contaminated soil claim?
Hi Laura – this has been shared with the township, though I’m not exactly sure what you’re speaking about debunking. These are baseline analysis of the soil at the Textile road site. These assessments were legally required as part of the purchase of those parcels, and conducted by a third party.